# GPT-6 Astra vs Claude Fable 5.1

> Astra and Fable 5.1 cost the same. Compare official benchmarks to see where Astra wins and where Claude wins.

Source: Giallo Studio (giallostudio.it) · Page: https://giallostudio.it/en/blog/gpt-6-astra-vs-fable-5-1 · Published: 2026-09-04 · Updated: 2026-09-04

**GPT-6 Astra** and **Claude Fable 5.1** They cost exactly the same amount: ten dollars per million incoming tokens, fifty outgoing tokens. At the top of the market the price stopped being a competitive lever, and the two main suppliers lined up on the same spot.

With list prices out of the equation, the comparison is decided entirely by what they do better. Data verified on **September 4, 2026**.

<div class="key-points">
  <p class="kp-title">In summary</p>
  <ul>
    <li><strong>Same price list</strong>: $10/50 per million tokens on both.</li>
    <li>Astra forward on <strong>terminal, automation and CAD</strong>.</li>
    <li>Fable 5.1 forward on <strong>Humanity's Last Exam</strong> by almost eight points.</li>
    <li>Fable 5.1 first on the <strong>intelligence index</strong> of Artificial Analysis.</li>
    <li>Fable 5.1 <strong>Reject</strong> most questions on three scientific tests.</li>
    <li>The numbers are <strong>published by OpenAI</strong>: it is not a neutral source.</li>
  </ul>
</div>

## How do Astra and Fable compare on specifications?

| Feature | GPT-6 Astra | Claude Fable 5.1 |
|---|---|---|
| Supplier | OpenAI | Anthropic |
| Input for 1M token | 10 $ | 10 $ |
| Output for 1M token | 50 $ | 50 $ |
| Context Window | 1.05M | 1M |
| Maximum Output | 128K | 128K |
| Knowledge limit date | 30 April 2026 | June 2026 |
| Declared latency | Fast mode available | the slowest in the family |

Here again the deadline plays in favor of the competing model: June 2026 for Fable 5.1 against late April for Astra. Two months, which do not change a decision but disprove the idea that the model announced later necessarily has the most recent knowledge.

## Where is Astra ahead of Fable?

| Benchmark | Astra | Fable 5.1 | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Terminal-Bench Science 0.1 | 64,6% | 52,6% | +12 points |
| BenchCAD | 95,9% | 84,3% | +11.6 points |
| AutomationBench | 41,4% | 31,4% | +10 points |
| FrontierMath Tier 4 (v2) | 97,6% | 87,8% | +9.8 points |
| DeepSWE v1.1 | 74,1% | 67,4% | +6.7 points |
| DB Migration (internal) | 63,9% | 57,8% | +6.1 points |
| HealthBench Professional | 63,4% | 58,1% | +5.3 points |
| Terminal-Bench 4.0 | 57,9% | 55,8% | +2.1 points |
| ExploitGym | 42,4% | 30,4% | +12 points |
| GPQA Diamond | 96,0% | 93,7% | +2.3 points |

The areas of strength are consistent with the rest of the ad: **terminal work**, **process automation**, **CAD Generation** and **Advanced Mathematics**.

On Terminal-Bench 4.0, however, the margin is only 2.1 points — much narrower than the communication suggests. And OpenAI declares that that result comes to about the **63% less estimated cost** compared to Fable 5.1, which is the most relevant data in the line.

## Where is Fable 5.1 ahead of Astra?

| Benchmark | Astra | Fable 5.1 |
|---|---|---|
| Humanity's Last Exam (with tool) | 57,2% | **65,0%** |
| AA Intelligence Index v4.1.1 | 61,2 | **65,7** |
| FrontierCode 1.1 Extended | 64,5% | 63,6% |
| FrontierCode 1.1 Main | 53,3% | 50,9% |

The first two lines matter a lot. **Humanity's Last Exam** is a test of difficult knowledge and Fable 5.1 is ahead by almost eight points. The **Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index** is a third-party measure, not an internal test, and sees Fable 5.1 first by a margin of 4.5 points.

<div class="callout"><strong>The Honest Reading</strong> At the same price, Astra is strongest in the <strong>run</strong> — terminal, automation, technical tools — and Fable 5.1 in <strong>know</strong> and in aggregate measures of general capacity. It is not a single verdict: they are two different profiles at the same cost.</div>

## Which footnotes change how the comparisons should be read?

Since these are tables published by one of the two contenders, footnotes count.

<ul class="checklist">
  <li>Up <strong>BenchCAD</strong> Claude scores reflect <strong>three changes</strong> to the evaluation</li>
  <li>Up <strong>ScreenSpot-Pro and ExploitGym</strong> the Fable scores quoted come from a variant with <strong>fewer safeguards</strong></li>
  <li>Fable 5 and 5.1 are <strong>excluded</strong> from LifeSciBench, GeneBench Pro and MedChemBench because they reject most questions</li>
  <li>Up <strong>OSWorld 2.0</strong> Claude scores use official settings, not Fable 5.1 system card settings</li>
  <li>All scores are the <strong>maximum at any level</strong> of reasoning</li>
</ul>

Exclusion from the three scientific tests deserves clarification: **It's not a defeat**. It is a choice of behavior of the model, which rejects those questions. For a company it can be a value or a problem depending on the domain in which it works, but presenting it as a low score would be incorrect.

## How do you choose between Astra and Fable in real cases?

**Laboratory automating terminal analysis.** Terminal-Bench Science gives twelve points of detachment in favor of Astra, with lower estimated cost. It is the least questionable area.

**Study answering complex specialist questions.** Humanity's Last Exam suggests Fable 5.1, ahead of almost eight points. If your job is to answer difficult questions of domination, the verdict overturns.

**Pharmaceutical or biomedical company.** Be wary of behavior: The notes point out that Fable models reject most questions on three scientific assessments. It must be verified on your domain before choosing, because a waste in production is a flow that stops.

## Which mistakes should you avoid when comparing Astra and Fable?

<ul class="checklist">
  <li><strong>Treating OpenAI tables as neutral</strong> on Claude.</li>
  <li><strong>Reading exclusion from a test as a defeat.</strong></li>
  <li><strong>Ignoring notes</strong> on modifications and variants used.</li>
  <li><strong>Searching for a unique winner</strong> where there are two different profiles.</li>
  <li><strong>Forgetting that the price is identical</strong>: only decides surrender.</li>
  <li><strong>Not checking refusals</strong> on their own domain.</li>
</ul>

## How should a company choose between Astra and Fable?

With the identical price list, the decision boils down to two numbers that only you can measure.

The first is **how many attempts are needed** to close a task. At the same rate, one model that closes on the first shot where the other requires two costs half. It is the only economic lever left and is invisible to published comparisons.

The second is **How They Mistaken**. A model that declares when information is missing produces a manageable queue; one that invents a plausible value produces errors that nobody will check. This can only be observed by examining the difficult cases one by one.

Then prepare ten real cases with three difficult ones and one that lacks the required data, and perform everything on both with the same prompt. Add at least one case to your domain boundary, to see where the behavioral boundaries fall.

<div class="callout"><strong>First of all this</strong> Ask yourself if you need this band. At $50 per million tokens in output, both of these models are oversized to rank, extract or respond from documents. Verification is in <a href="https://giallostudio.it/en/blog/when-cheap-ai-model-is-enough">when an economic model is enough</a>.</div>

## How much does Astra really cost compared with Fable?

At the same price list, the most relevant statement of the ad is not a score but an estimate of expenditure. OpenAI declares that Astra achieves its results by consuming less.

| Benchmark | Result | Cost declared vs Fable 5.1 |
|---|---|---|
| Terminal-Bench Science 0.1 | 64.6% vs 52.6% | **~31% less** |
| Terminal-Bench 4.0 | 57.9% vs 55.8% | **~63% less** |
| BenchCAD | 95.9% vs 84.3% | **~86% less** |

The line on Terminal-Bench 4.0 is the most instructive: two points ahead in scoring, but the **63% less estimated cost**. If it was confirmed on its own case, it would be more important than the score itself — because at the same price list the cost per task depends entirely on how many tokens it takes to get there.

It must be clearly stated that it is **manufacturer estimates on individual benchmarks**, not of independent measurements nor of a general rule. But they are verifiable: fifty real tasks on both models are enough, counting the tokens actually invoiced.

<div class="callout"><strong>Why count them and not estimate them</strong> On models that reason before responding, intermediate tokens do not appear in the final text but are paid for as output. Estimating consumption by the length of responses systematically leads to underestimation, and on a $50 tariff the error is seen in the invoice.</div>

## How much does speed matter when choosing between Astra and Fable?

There is a difference between the two patterns that score tables do not capture.

The Anthropic documentation places Fable 5.1 at the slow end of its family. OpenAI, for its part, offers for Astra a **Fast mode** which promises up to twice the speed at twice the price, and declares task completion 1.9 times faster with the updated Codex scaffolding.

In agent scenarios the latency is multiplied by the number of steps: a twelve-step stream pays the response time twelve times. If your agent works while someone is watching, this difference weighs as much as a benchmark point — the reasoning is in [AI models latency by comparison](https://giallostudio.it/en/blog/ai-model-latency-comparison), while the comparison with the other flagship Anthropic model is in [GPT-6 Astra vs Claude Opus 5](https://giallostudio.it/en/blog/opus-5-vs-gpt-6-astra).

If, on the other hand, it works at night, the latency comes out of the decision and it is better to look only at quality and cost per task.

## How do Astra and Fable differ on behavioral limits?

One last item that in production counts more than you think.

The announcement notes signal that the Fable models **reject most questions** on three scientific evaluations, and that some of the cited scores come from a variant with less protection. On the other hand, Astra reaches the Critical threshold on cybersecurity and consequently **rejects advanced cyber tasks**, with controls that can also stop legitimate work — in API the task stops.

Both models therefore have boundaries, but they fall at different points. For a real project the question is not which is more permissive, but **where the boundaries with respect to your domain fall**.

That's why it's worth including at least a couple of cases on the test stand at the edge of your industry: not to force anything, but to find out at the evaluation stage —and not in production.where the model stops.

## When does the choice between Astra and Fable not matter?

Let's close with the observation that makes half of this comparison unnecessary for most readers.

Both of these models cost fifty dollars per million tokens out. On a system that processes twenty thousand requests per month with responses from a thousand tokens, it is a thousand dollars per month of output alone — before the system prompt, reasoning tokens and failed attempts.

To classify messages, extract fields from invoices, or respond from a document base, **Neither is necessary.**: there is an intermediate band at one fifth of the price that closes the same tasks, and an economic one at one fiftieth for works of pure recognition.

The comparison between Astra and Fable 5.1 becomes relevant when the task is genuinely difficult: autonomous agents on long chains, analysis that cross many sources, specialized technical work where an error costs more than the call. Out of there, the correct choice is lower — and it occurs in an hour with ten real cases.

### A final verification before deciding

If after the test the two models are equivalent on your cases — and it is a frequent outcome on this range — the decision shifts to operational factors that it is legitimate to consider: which ecosystem already knows your team, what tools exist around, where you know how to solve a problem when it occurs at six o'clock in the evening.

It's not a fallback choice. At the same measured result, the team's familiarity with the platform is worth more than a few decimal places on a benchmark, because it results in faster intervention times when something doesn't work.


Three readings to complete the picture. The complete picture of the model is in [GPT-6 Astra: what it is and what changes](https://giallostudio.it/en/blog/what-is-gpt-6-astra). For the economic part, which on this band decides more than capacity, the reference is [GPT-6 Astra: prices and how to pay](https://giallostudio.it/en/blog/gpt-6-astra-pricing). And to see if your task really justifies it, the verification is in [GPT-6 Astra: all official benchmarks](https://giallostudio.it/en/blog/gpt-6-astra-benchmarks).

## Conclusion

Astra and Fable 5.1 cost identical and offer two different profiles: Astra stronger in performing technical tasks, Fable 5.1 stronger on difficult knowledge and third-party aggregate measures.

With the price out of the equation, the choice is made as to how many attempts are needed and how the two go wrong —two things you don't find in any table and measure in half a day.

If you want to choose on your data instead of ads, [Giallo Studio](https://giallostudio.it/en/services) can help you turn the problem into a real workflow.

## Frequently asked questions

### How much do GPT-6 Astra and Claude Fable 5.1 cost?

Exactly the same: $10 per million input tokens and $50 per million output tokens, according to both providers' official documentation. Price therefore drops out of the equation.

### Who wins on benchmarks?

In the OpenAI tables, Astra is ahead on Terminal-Bench 4.0, Terminal-Bench Science, AutomationBench and BenchCAD. Fable 5.1 is ahead on Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index and Humanity's Last Exam.

### What is the most significant gap in favor of Fable 5.1?

Humanity's Last Exam with tools: 65.0% versus Astra's 57.2%, almost eight points. This is the result that departs furthest from the overall narrative of OpenAI's announcement.

### What about the one in favor of Astra?

Terminal-Bench Science 0.1: 64.6% versus 52.6%, with about 31% less estimated API cost according to OpenAI.

### Are comparisons neutral?

No: they are published by OpenAI. Some notes specify that Claude's scores on certain tests reflect changes to the evaluation or come from variants with fewer safeguards.

### How do you choose at the same price?

On your own use cases. With identical prices, the decision shifts to how many attempts it takes to complete a task and how the two models make mistakes.
